Pages

Saturday, September 24, 2016

Lunar Loop-the-Loop

This question comes from my girlfriend Marika's grandfather, who studied physics in his youth: What shape does the moon trace as the Earth orbits the Sun?

The idea is, the Moon is going in (approximately) a circle around the Earth, while the Earth is going in (approximately) a circle around the Sun.  This is a surprisingly simple situation to model using a parametric equation:
The 'R's are the radii of the Earth's and Moon's orbits, and the 'T's are the time each takes to complete a circuit.  This type of curve is called an epitrochoid, and can take on some interesting shapes:

The general form for this type of curve is
We can relate this to the earlier equations with
The site I linked above states that there will be loops if b > a/c, so let's plug in some values (from Wikipedia):
Nowhere close, a result borne out by the plot:
If you look carefully, you can see that's not quite circular, but it's awfully close.  Thanks for a great question, George!

[Edit: If you're curious about the b > a/c condition, you can think of it this way – There will be a loop anytime the Moon is moving backwards faster than the Earth is moving forwards.  The speed of each is given by 2πR/T, and if you plug in the R and T relations for a, b, and c, you'll see that's exactly what b > a/c means.]

1 comment:

  1. Orion suggested that I post my non-formulaic solution. I'll give away the punch line - the important piece of data is that the earth and moon are close together compared with the earth and sun.
    I don't have a graphic app to illustrate, but if you draw this yourself it will likely make more sense.
    1. The number of degrees in a circle is close enough to the number of days in the year, that we can say the earth travels one degree a day. So draw a 30 degree arc of a big circle to represent the earth's path in a month.
    2. Put 8-9 dots on the arc to represent evenly spaced locations in the earth's orbit.
    3. With a contrasting color, put a dot near each earth to represent the moon. The first and last should have the moon in the same spot to represent the full cycle is complete.
    4. Connect the contrasting color dots, and voila, you have the slightly wavy circle that Orion showed.

    ReplyDelete